Declassified NIE excerpts show Iraq war fostered terrorism

George W. Bush’s decision to declassify and release selected parts of the National Intelligence Estimate isn’t doing his attempt to sell the Iraq war to a skeptical American public any good. It only points out the many failures of his flawed policies.

Katherine Shrader and Jennifer Loven of the Associated Press report:

The war in Iraq has become a "cause celebre" for Islamic extremists, breeding deep resentment of the U.S. that probably will get worse before it gets better, federal intelligence analysts conclude in a report at odds with President Bush’s portrayal of a world growing safer.

In the bleak report, declassified and released Tuesday on Bush’s orders, the nation’s most veteran analysts conclude that despite serious damage to the leadership of al-Qaida, the threat from Islamic extremists has spread both in numbers and in geographic reach.

Bush and his top advisers have said the formerly classified assessment of global terrorism supported their arguments that the world is safer because of the war. But more than three pages of stark judgments warning about the spread of terrorism contrasted with the administration’s glass-half-full declarations.

"If this trend continues, threats to U.S. interests at home and abroad will become more diverse, leading to increasing attacks worldwide," the document says. "The confluence of shared purpose and dispersed actors will make it harder to find and undermine jihadist groups."

The intelligence assessment, completed in April, has stirred a heated election-season argument over the course of U.S. national security in the years following the 2003 U.S.-led invasion of Iraq.

Virtually all assessments of the current situation were bad news. The report’s few positive notes were couched in conditional terms, depending on successful completion of difficult tasks ahead for the U.S. and its allies. In one example, analysts concluded that more responsive political systems in Muslim nations could erode support for jihadist extremists.

Bush ordered a declassified section of the secret report released after several days of criticism sparked by portions that were leaked to the news media over the weekend.

At a news conference, Bush said critics who believe the Iraq war has worsened terrorism are naive and mistaken, noting that al-Qaida and other groups have found inspiration to attack for more than a decade. "My judgment is, if we weren’t in Iraq, they’d find some other excuse, because they have ambitions," he said.

The unclassified document said:

• The increased role of Iraqis in managing the operations of al-Qaida in Iraq might lead the terror group’s veteran foreign fighters to refocus their efforts outside that country.

• While Iran and Syria are the most active state sponsors of terror, many other countries will be unable to prevent their resources from being exploited by terrorists.

• The underlying factors that are fueling the spread of the extremist Muslim movement outweigh its vulnerabilities. These factors are entrenched grievances and a slow pace of reform in home countries, rising anti-U.S. sentiment and the Iraq war.

• Groups "of all stripes" will increasingly use the Internet to communicate, train, recruit and obtain support.

Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf, a U.S. ally in Washington for a Thursday meeting with Bush, found himself drawn into the political dispute. He was asked in a CNN interview about an assertion in his new book that he opposed the invasion of Iraq because he feared that it would only encourage extremists and leave the world less safe.

"I stand by it, absolutely," Musharraf said. "It has made the world a more dangerous place."

White House homeland security adviser Frances Fragos Townsend took issue with one of the report’s most damning conclusions: that the number of jihadists has increased.

"I don’t think there’s any question that there’s an increase in rhetoric," she said. But "I think it’s difficult to count the number of true jihadists that are willing to commit murder or kill themselves in the process."

The intelligence assessment also lays out weaknesses of the movement that analysts say must be exploited if its spread is to be slowed. For instance, they note that extremists want to see the establishment of strict Islamic governments in the Arab world — a development they say would be unpopular with most Muslims.

The report also argues that the loss of key al-Qaida leaders — Osama bin Laden, Ayman al-Zawahri and Abu Musab al-Zarqawi — in "rapid succession" would probably cause the group to fracture. Al-Zarqawi was killed in June, but the top two al-Qaida leaders have remained elusive for years.

National intelligence estimates are compilations of the best thinking of U.S. intelligence agencies, meant to provide the broadest guidance to government policymakers.

But they can be wrong. A 2002 assessment, for example, concluded that Iraq had continued its development of weapons of mass destruction, held arsenals of chemical and biological weapons and "probably will have a nuclear weapon during this decade." None of those assertions turned out to be true.

Hours before the terrorism report was made public, Democrats seized on the political ammunition. Sens. Hillary Clinton of New York and Carl Levin of Michigan both said release of the key findings alone wouldn’t give Americans enough information, and they accused the administration of selective declassification.

House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., sought a rare secret session of the House to discuss the report’s classified findings. Her request was rejected — 217-171 — on a nearly straight party-line vote. In an interview, she said the intelligence estimate "is not a corroboration of what the president is saying. It is a contradiction of what the president is saying."

Writes Brad Knowlton in the International Herald Tribune:

The war in Iraq has become a “cause célèbre” for Islamic militants, “breeding a deep resentment” of the United States in the Muslim world, according to declassified excerpts from a major intelligence report that were released late this afternoon.

“The Iraqi jihad is shaping a new generation of terrorist leaders and operatives; perceived jihadist success there would inspire more fighters to continue the struggle elsewhere,” the excerpts said.

The excerpts — just over three pages from a document said to be 30 pages — were ordered declassified by President Bush. Mr. Bush said earlier today that he was loath to declassify any classified document, but that news reports about the intelligence assessment could have led to “confusion” about its findings. The New York Times disclosed some of the findings over the weekend, showing that the Iraq war had invigorated Islamic radicalism and worsened the global terrorist threat.

The excerpts from the intelligence report pointed to a spread of terrorist activity globally for at least the next five years and said terrorists were adapting to the tactics used against them. “If this trend continues, threats to U.S. interests at home and abroad will become more diverse, leading to increasing attacks worldwide,” they said.

“Jihadists, although a small percentage of Muslims, are increasing in both number and geographic dispersion,” said the excerpted document, representing the key judgments of a National Intelligence Estimate completed in April 2006 and reflecting the consensus of the nation’s 16 intelligence agencies.

The shorter document, drawn from the April assessment titled “Trends in Global Terrorism: Implications for the United States,” was released by the office of the director of national security amid rising political pressure from Democrats for its declassification.

Instead of making the case for the Iraq war, Bush’s decision to release parts of the report only add to the knowledge that his ill-fated order to invade Iraq has created new havens for terrorism, increased hatred towards the United States and made the United States less safe than it was before September 11, 2001.

6 Responses to "Declassified NIE excerpts show Iraq war fostered terrorism"

  1. david bier  September 27, 2006 at 2:32 pm

    This whole thing reminds me of Iraq intelligence cherry-picking. Why can’t we see the entire report? Certainly out of 18 spy agencies we could come up with more than 30 pages of information in a year, so I suspect this entire thing is summary anyway. If the other 27 pages aren’t damaging to Bush’s agenda, why keep them hidden?

  2. John Mulqueen  September 27, 2006 at 4:44 pm

    The AP report continues the mistake of call Zarqawi an Al Queda leaders. He was not as Lawrence Wright has pointed out in articles in the Washington Post. That is a Bush scam to hide the fact that terrorism has many faces, the insurgency in Iraq is not exclusively an Al Queda affair.

  3. Fred  September 27, 2006 at 5:37 pm

    The released excerpts can be found here; I think that they are worth reading:
    http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/5383614.stm

  4. R. Ruffian  September 28, 2006 at 12:47 am

    The NIE is a gloomy document. Besides listing increased threats to the US, there is a huge spillover effect in Europe where there is a target rich environment with a large increasingly radicalized Muslim minority willing to become Jihadist.

    If what the Whitehouse released above is the sanitized version of the NIE can you imagine how bad the entire report is?

  5. Jennifer  September 28, 2006 at 1:15 am

    Insurgent..a person, who takes part in forcible opposition or armed resistance to an established government or authority; rebel.
    Isn’t that what the fore-fathers of the USA did against the British Empire? Isn’t this why we/you celebrate the 4th of July?They were REBELS with a cause to make America FREE!
    Think, if another major emprie took over this country…would not the local men defend their lands, resources, their family??????????????
    That’s how you breed resistance…a hatred of the country invading your sovereign homeland…ask any American Indian…ask me.
    In the end, our prophecies will be fullfiled and all these lies will be exposed!
    including the missing/deleted pages from this supposed disclosure of secret documents. I wonder how they will answer to the Great Spirit/God?
    J

  6. David Rosenberg  September 28, 2006 at 1:40 am

    Did we really need the NIE to tell us the obvious? The pieces of the report released, proved or comfirmed what most knew already.
    Terrorism was already born and being used before we invaded Afghanistan and Irag. The Republicans are trying to use that to deflect the statement it is worse after we attacked. If terrorism hasn’t increased, we would have claimed victory over
    Iraq Two maybe Three years ago. Attacking the Two countries has enraged the Muslim world. It has made it easier to recruit new fighters and grown hate toward the USA.
    It boggles the mind how Bush and his cronies can take this report to mean we are winning and advancing toward victory on the war of terror and in Iraq.

Comments are closed.