Republicans Balk at Bush Budget Cuts

President Bush’s proposed spending cuts drew worried criticism on Tuesday from the Republican heads of congressional budget committees, and key party members said his priorities were not binding.

But the lawmakers expressed a shared goal of austerity as Bush said they must make “difficult choices” to rein in the budget deficit, which has surged to record levels during a presidency that inherited a surplus.

A top White House official said Bush was prepared to veto spending bills for the first time if necessary.

Bush sent Congress a $2.57 trillion budget plan for the 2006 fiscal year on Monday which proposes sweeping cuts across the budget and eliminates or reduces 150 programs. The Republican-controlled Congress is supposed to pass its own version by April 15, which will set spending limits for the year.

“The Congress doesn’t have to stick to these (White House) priorities,” said Senate Budget Committee Chairman Judd Gregg, a New Hampshire Republican.

“There are some programs in there I have heartburn about.”

House Budget Committee Chairman Jim Nussle, an Iowa Republican, warned his panel not to refuse spending cuts unless they could come up with alternative savings.

“Put up or shut up,” he said. “You’ve got to come forward with a proposal. It’s not good enough to just complain.”

But Nussle admitted he was worried about proposed farm-aid cuts which could affect Iowa, a farming state where he may run for governor. “I don’t like some of the cuts I’ve seen in the agricultural budget,” he said.

Both chairmen, who are charged with setting the spending limits for Congress, said the key is to tackle automatic programs that do not require lawmakers’ approval each year, such as Medicaid health care for the poor. Bush’s budget already seeks $45 billion in Medicaid savings over 10 years.

These mandatory programs account for around 55 percent of the budget. They require legislation to change, and Nussle said he may use the budget procedure to instruct committees in charge of those programs to make changes.

Bush’s budget forecasts a record $427 billion deficit for 2005 including war costs. For 2006 he expects a deficit of $390 billion, but that is without any spending in Iraq and Afghanistan. The figures compare to a $236 billion surplus in 2000.

Democrats say Bush’s tax cuts caused the deficit. Republicans blame the wars and the recession.


Other important Republicans also lined up to complain about the new budget proposal.

Maine Republican Senator Olympia Snowe, asked if she had problems with Bush’s budget, said “How long do you have?” She was one of four Republicans who refused to agree to a budget last year over deficit concerns.

Senate Agriculture Committee Chairman Saxby Chambliss, a Georgia Republican, said farm-aid cuts were “wrong.”

Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, a Tennessee Republican, urged lawmakers to take time to digest the budget and not to “lock down” their positions.

But he also distinguished Congress’ budget priorities from Bush’s. “The president’s priorities are reflected in that budget. You will see the reflection of the Senate’s priorities and the House over the next several weeks,” he said.

Bush dispatched Treasury Secretary John Snow and White House budget director Josh Bolten to Capitol Hill to defend the spending cuts.

Bolten said Bush would veto spending bills if needed.

Despite similar rhetoric from some Republicans last year, Congress stuck to Bush’s requested $822 billion limit for the spending that needs congressional approval. Bush wants a limit of $840 billion this year.

Democrats are also furious with Bush’s budget plans. They say it stints on funding for crucial programs that help the poor, that it shows a misleading reduction in the deficit because it leaves out war spending and the cost of Bush’s plan to reform Social Security and extend tax cuts.

“It will put us on a path of endless deficits and a Mount Everest on mountainous debt,” said South Carolina Democrat John Spratt.

(Additional reporting by Donna Smith)

© Reuters 2005. All rights reserved.