Unresolved disputes threaten health care reform

Just a few unsolved problems — and one final sales job — stand between House Democratic leaders and a landmark vote on President Barack Obama’s promised remake of the nation’s health care system.

Unfortunately for the Democrats, the unresolved issues are among the most vexing out there: abortion and immigration.

And although they’re confident they’ll succeed, Democratic leaders have yet to nail down the votes they’ll need to pass their sweeping bill. They’re aiming for floor action to begin as early as Friday and finish before Veterans Day, Nov. 11.

Or, as Majority Leader Steny Hoyer put it when asked when the House would take up the health care bill, “Friday or Saturday or Monday or Tuesday.”

“We want to make sure it’s correct,” Hoyer, D-Md., told reporters Monday.

The 10-year, $1.2 trillion bill would extend coverage to tens of millions of uninsured Americans with a new requirement that almost everyone get insured, and give subsidies to help lower-income people afford plans. Businesses would be required to cover their employees, and insurance companies would no longer be able to turn people away because of their health status.

Democratic leaders unveiled the bill with fanfare last week, a 1,990-page plan that sought to satisfy the concerns of both liberals and moderates while combining separate health bills passed by three different committees over the summer.

House leaders have made progress winning over liberals to back a new government insurance plan in the bill that’s weaker than what liberals preferred. But they haven’t quite closed the deal with enough members of their caucus. An initial vote tally showed them falling short of the 218-vote majority they need, according to Democratic aides.

“The bill’s improved,” said Rep. Jason Altmire, D-Pa., one of many undecided lawmakers, citing fewer taxes and more deficit-reducing measures. But, Altmire said, “I’m not sure it’s there yet.”

Across the Capitol, senators are waiting to see the final language and price tag on a health bill that Majority Leader Harry Reid and a few other top officials wrote in secret. It’s not clear when those details will be available and Reid, D-Nev., may not be able to begin debate on the issue until the week before Thanksgiving.

Determined to avoid being accused of not reading their bill, House Democrats met late Monday to do just that, going over the legislation section by section in a room in the basement of the Capitol.

Anti-abortion Democrats were circulating language to strengthen prohibitions in the bill against federal funding of abortion. The bill stipulates that people getting federal subsidies would have to use their own money to get abortions, but that division is not clear enough to satisfy some lawmakers. Lawmakers are considering language that would make a more straightforward declaration against use of federal funds for abortion.

On immigration, it’s still not settled whether illegal immigrants would be allowed to shop for insurance within a new purchasing exchange. Some lawmakers say that even if they use their own money to buy private plans they would be getting a benefit from the federally established exchange. The White House does not want illegal immigrants to access the exchange, and the Senate bill would keep them out.

After spending months criticizing Democratic health care plans, House Republicans are preparing to unveil one of their own, though Minority Leader John Boehner was short on details when he described it to reporters Monday.

He said it would omit one of the central provisions in Democratic bills — a ban on the insurance industry’s practice of denying coverage on the basis of pre-existing medical conditions. Instead, he said the Republicans would encourage creation of insurance pools for high-risk individuals and take other steps to ease their access to coverage.

Boehner also said Republicans would propose limits on medical malpractice lawsuits in what he said was an attempt to reduce the cost of coverage.

Despite their internal divisions, many Democrats are eager to vote for a health overhaul bill — even those who hadn’t quite committed themselves to doing so.

“We fail to pass health care reform at our own peril,” said Rep. Gerry Connolly, D-Va., though he has yet to agree to support the bill. “Our base expects health care reform. … You can’t distance yourself from your base and expect to succeed.”


AP Special Correspondent David Espo contributed to this report.


  1. Carl Nemo

    Yep this legislation is a prime example of our Congressional “Tower of Babel” syndrome. Hopefully as the ancient tower project failed due to a confusion of tongues inflicted upon the workers, the same will occur concerning this nightmarish POS legislation.

    No good will come from this bill, only national grief both financially and functionally.

    Carl Nemo **==

  2. Carl Nemo

    Hi Almandine,

    All I can say about this M.D.’s letter to Senator Bayh is it being one big informative “OUCH”! I’ve made an attempt to read through this bill, but as I do so and have my similar discoveries about this POS legislation, my heart goes into a virtual swoon, knowing this is not simply a bill concerned with health care, but an incremental push by our out of control, “Big Brother Government” to regulate every aspect of our lives.

    Some people would simply tag it as benign socialism descending upon this nation, but rest assured once the healthcare bureaucrats administering this nightmare get moving, they will in no time flat have a draconian enforcement arm with badges, guns and a handful of rubber-stamped warrants to kick everyone’s door for the purpose of enforcing this NWO “hardcore communism” upon us. Rest assured many ugly stories will unfold in the months and years to come concerning this legislation no differently than those we’ve heard concerning Homeland Security and their rogue subsidiary TSA both indemnified by the unconstitutional, unchallenged “Patriot Act”.

    I’m heartsick that crap legislation like this is virtually on the fast track for passage. I’ve both written snail mail, emailed and have called my Washington State 3rd District rep, Congressman Brian Baird’s office, but with him I’ll say that as a Democrat he’s never met a federally supplied buck that he wouldn’t enjoy squandering on some feelgood project with faux healthcare for all being surely one of them. The same goes for my two Senators; ie., Patty Murray and Maria Cantwell.

    Thanks again for the link. Mind you the good doctor evaluated the bill when it was only 1000 pages in length, exposing its nightmarish aspects. Well now there’s another 1000 pages of even more evil, agendist gobbledygook to cope with post passage…!

    I’m confident our traitorous, corporately controlled Congress will follow their NWO script to the “T” with passage of this personally invasive nightmare they call legislation.

    Carl Nemo **==

  3. almandine

    Freakin’ doomed, as the Mogambo would say…

    and regarding doomed – it is some consolation, not much I admit, that when the Bernanke / Geithner chickens come home to roost, many of those STUPID Reps and Senators will have no more to fall back on than the rest of us.

    Now THAT is gallows humor.