|
Latest Stories
Recent blog posts
|
July 23, 2008 - 7:56am.
Agent Ali Soufan, an al-Qaida expert and star witness for the prosecution, said Tuesday the Guantanamo Bay Navy base is the only place in the world where he has not informed suspects of a right against self-incrimination. "The way it was explained to us is Guantanamo Bay is an intelligence collection point," he said. Defense lawyers asked the judge in Salim Hamdan's trial to throw out all the Guantanamo interrogations, arguing that intelligence-gathering sessions should not be used against him in court. But Judge Keith Allred, a Navy captain, ruled Monday that constitutional protections against self-incrimination do not apply to the man declared an "enemy combatant." Hamdan, a former driver for Osama bin Laden, is charged with conspiracy and aiding terrorism. His lawyers have cast him as a low-level employee of the terrorist leader without any role in al-Qaida. Other agents from the FBI and the Naval Criminal Investigative Service who interrogated Hamdan said at pretrial hearings last week that they were instructed not to advise Guantanamo detainees of rights, but Soufan is the first to provide a reason. Soufan said the Guantanamo policy was an exception to a practice he followed even in Hamdan's native Yemen, where he interviewed suspects in the investigation into the 2000 bombing of the USS Cole. He is expected to testify Wednesday about two interrogations of Hamdan in 2002. A judge's ruling is pending on whether to admit a third interrogation he conducted in May 2003, as defense lawyers review hundreds of pages of newly released prison records for evidence of coercion. The judge suppressed other statements by Hamdan in Afghanistan because he made them under "highly coercive" conditions including isolation and beatings. In opening arguments Tuesday, prosecutors said Hamdan helped bin Laden evade U.S. retribution after the Sept. 11 attacks and ferried weapons for the Taliban in Afghanistan. "You will not see evidence from the government that the accused ever fired a shot," said prosecutor and Navy Lt. Cmdr. Timothy Stone. "But what you will see is testimony regarding the accused's role in al-Qaida, how he became a member of al-Qaida and how he helped, facilitated and provided material support for that organization." Two U.S. military officers testified that two surface-to-air missiles were in the car Hamdan was driving when Afghan forces captured him at a roadblock in November 2001. Hamdan faces a maximum life sentence if convicted. The trial is expected to take three to four weeks. The U.S. says it plans to prosecute about 80 prisoners at Guantanamo. Copyright © 2008 The Associated Press
Capitol Hill Blue's columnists, blogs and reader comments Capitol Hill Blue is an independent, non-partisan news site that belongs to no political party and subscribes to no political or philosophical point-of-view. Our columnists are welcome to their opinions but readers should understand that their views do not necessarily reflect the editorial policies of this web site. We also welcome comments to selected opinion columns and in our popular ReaderRant discussion forum. Please remember, however, that we believe in civility on this web site and comments may be reviewed, moderated or removed if we feel they contain obscenities, racism, bigotry, anti-Semitic remarks or attack other posters. Our goal is reasoned discussion on issues facing this nation and we do not feel that goal is served by personal attacks and by seeing how many cute adjectives you can attach to an elected official or politician's name. Copyright © 2008 Capitol Hill Blue
|
User login
|
"Allred, a Navy captain,
Submitted by ekaton on July 23, 2008 - 8:17am."Allred, a Navy captain, ruled Monday that constitutional protections against self-incrimination do not apply to the man declared an "enemy combatant."
How interesting that Navy captains are now allowed to interpret the constitution. I always thought that was the job of the civilian courts, not military kangaroo courts.
I guess I better go back and read the constitution again and find the part where it states that the military is above the law, and that military officers at the level of Captain, and presumably above that rank, have the duty to interpret the law.
-- Kent Shaw
You are correct Kent. But
Submitted by Sandra Price on July 23, 2008 - 8:33am.You are correct Kent. But the Administration has mixed up our Constitution and our Geneva Conventions to the point of removing their authority. Even the Supreme Court is hog tied under the threat of the next Justice coming in and changing the balance. Not even I, when working against Bush being elected in 2000 could have imagined the damage he would inflict on America.
I hope all Americans can learn from these last 8 years that handing one man total dictatorship of our government could destroy our civil rights. It is time we opened up the White House and Congress and let some fresh air in.
Sorry, but we suffer from 4
Submitted by adamrussell on July 23, 2008 - 9:38pm.Sorry, but we suffer from 4 year amnesia. I think in our fantasy of 2 equal political parties we are unable to keep the knowledge that one party is a culture of corruption and deceit.
I concur. -- Kent Shaw
Submitted by ekaton on July 23, 2008 - 11:22am.I concur.
-- Kent Shaw
Hooray for Captain I can
Submitted by bryan mcclellan on July 24, 2008 - 12:01am.Hooray for Captain I can handle the truth for ya.
Or is it pity the fool stuck working for the fool on the hill.
We need to remind these jokers, It's not a goddamn movie.