News Categories



Capitol Hill Blue is a not-for-profit, non-commercial experiment in on-line journalism published as an information resource for our readers. All material is © 2006 Capitol Hill Blue. For more information, please check out our FAQ. We take your privacy seriously at Capitol Hill Blue.
CHB Home / Half-Shell Home/ Print This Page / Email this page

Murtha calls Pentagon's top general a liar

March 5, 2006 04:55 PM / Capitol Hillbillies .
Rep. John Murtha, the decorated ex-Marine turned Iraq war critic, Sunday called the Pentagon's chairman of the Joint Chiefs a liar for his rosy view of the war. The general acknowledged Sunday that "anything can happen" in Iraq, but he said things aren't as bad as some say. "I wouldn't put a great big smiley face on it, but I would say they're going very, very well from everything you look at."

The comments drew criticism that Gen. Peter Pace is glossing over problems in the three-year-old U.S. campaign.

"Why would I believe him?" asked Rep. Murtha, D-Pa., a major critic of the Bush administration's handling of the war. "This administration, including the president, (has) mischaracterized this war for the last two years."

Pace, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, cited political progress such as holding elections and writing a constitution as well as military progress like training Iraqi security forces.

"No matter where you look _ at their military, their police, their society _ things are much better this year than they were last," Pace said on NBC's "Meet the Press."

Murtha, responding to Pace in an appearance on CBS' "Face the Nation," said that Iraq has 60 percent unemployment, oil production below prewar levels, and water service to only 30 percent of the population.

American troops are doing everything they can militarily but "are caught in a civil war," said Murtha, a former Marine who has called on the administration to bring U.S. troops home.

"There's two participants fighting for survival and fighting for supremacy inside that country," he said of ethnic divisions. "And that's my definition of a civil war."

Murtha added: "The rhetoric is so frustrating _ when they keep making statements which are very optimistic, and then it turns out to be the opposite. ... And the public has caught on to that, and they're very pessimistic about the outcome."

Pace and Murtha spoke as Iraqis continued a stalemate over forming a new government, a delay that has prevented parliament from meeting since it was elected Dec. 15.

Pressure mounted Sunday on Prime Minister Ibrahim al-Jaafari to give up his bid for a new term amid anger over the recent surge in sectarian killings that has complicated already snarled negotiations on a new Iraqi government.

Pace said the violent firestorm that followed the bombing of a revered Shiite mosque two weeks ago had forced Iraqis to look into "that abyss" and realize "that's not where they want to go."

"Anything can happen, I agree," Pace said, then added: "I believe the Iraqi people have shown in the last week to 10 days that they do not want civil war."

Ending the insurgency depends not only on military efforts but also on whether the Iraqi government can give the people what they want, Pace said. He said the number of people in the insurgency will drop if people see that the new government can come through with jobs and services.

"If you have an opportunity to get a job and feed your family, you're much less likely to accept $100 to go plant a bomb inside a road," Pace said.

Sen. Richard Lugar, chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, said the U.S. must stick with the Iraqis.

"They're talking about putting their act together," Lugar, R-Ind., said on CBS. "Now, the fact is that they may or may not be successful, but we better hope that they are, because the consequences for our country and the war against terror are very fateful if they are not."

© 2006 The Associated Press

© Copyright 2006 by Capitol Hill Blue

Comments

The entire military is fed this stuff. Those who aren't being shot at believe the whole package. Ask my wife's brother, who's a string player in the Army band, who regularly emails the current line, then blocks the replies he doesn't like.

Posted by mr.ed at March 5, 2006 05:14 PM

What else must happen to call it a civil war?

Posted by renate at March 5, 2006 06:30 PM

Seriously, you dont think for a moment that any career military person is going to say anything that might go "against the grain" of this whole "lying administration", do you???

Posted by Jim Nodine at March 5, 2006 07:43 PM

With no WMD found somebody lie, now 2,506 soldiers dead and 22,500 severely injured, 64% of Americans believe Dumbya’s bogus Iraq war was a “deadly mistake". 81% of Americans think Iraq will end up in a civil war which is now spiraling toward civil war with 138,000 U.S. troops caught in the middle. Would someone please tell Pete Pace what happening so an effective strategy can be implemented to change this situation.

Posted by k-man at March 5, 2006 08:24 PM

Quote:a nation of sheep deserves a government of wolves!this cabal in washington has been prevaricating since day one of their illegal invasion. the sooner dush is impeached the better for this once great nation

Posted by buddha at March 5, 2006 08:26 PM

the real military leaders walked when Rummy came on board, these are just the political hacks.

Posted by Joseph Irwin at March 5, 2006 08:53 PM

How many more people have to die to wake these assholes up?

Posted by glenn at March 5, 2006 09:18 PM

How can a soldier have so many medals and stars and still be an idiot..

Posted by JW at March 5, 2006 09:54 PM

These fucking neo-conservatives are going to blow up the world with their fascist bullshit - and I.m a Republican!

Posted by Tim at March 5, 2006 11:36 PM

Peter Pace has demonstrated what is wrong and why we are loosing the war in Iraq. They define victory by a set of arbitrary metrics; writing constitutions, holding elections, training local military and police.

Sadly, each of their 'victories' only aids the enemy.

Yes, they have held two successful elections in Iraq and both times radical Shia have won.

Yes, they did approve a constitution that the majority in the center provinces rejected - by contrast all thirteen original colonies ratified our constitution.

Yes, they are training military and police. It is no secret that the vast majority in both institutions are Shia. The Sunnies are not signing up. What is worse, much of the police force has been infiltrated by the Badr brigades and the Mahdi Army. Both are loyal not to the government but to Shia parties. American and British trained police in Basra enforce a religious code not unlike the code enforced by the Taliban in Afghanistan.

The American armed forces are aiding the take-over of Iraq by the allies of Iran. How that serves the interests of America escapes me. This is progress? This is victory? God save America from any more Bush 'victories,' many more victories like these and there won't be anything left to save.

Posted by Mark D at March 6, 2006 12:01 AM

Hello All !

It should be NO SECRET or SURPRISE that General Peter Pace or ANY OTHER GENERAL having ANYTHING to do with this insanity in Iraq that a very stubborn and uncaring President has decided he will stay the course is preaching the "PARTY LINE" no matter how foolish they sound. THAT IS THEIR JOB

If ANY military officer, certainly above the rank of o-6 EVER spoke the truth that THEY KNEW TO BE TRUE, they would be retired, fired or sent to Greenland to guard the gate and monitor polar bears.

Frankly it has to one degree or another ALWAYS been that way but this administration with it's foolish and stupid voyages into almost everything they do has taken it to a much higher "art form"

Their vindictiveness knows no bounds.

They have been lying to the American peole for the last five years and the "word" to ANY military person is , BACK US UP OR YOU WILL BE SORRY.

Those that make JCS and any other cabinet level or advisory rank are chosen for their ability to preach the party line and not waiver no matter how foolish they may sound. They allow themselves to be programmed so to speak and the best of the lot move up the chain.

Some never learn, even when they retire from "natural and honorable causes"

Posted by TRUTH 101 at March 6, 2006 09:14 AM

Gen. Pace, Chair of JCS is a political appointee. Hasn't everyone noticed that it's always "retired" military rank who speak forthrightly about Iraq? Murtha speaks for the active-duty troops when he asserts that the US military is in an increasingly dangerous position in Iraq:

"We're in a civil war now; it's just that not everybody's joined in," said retired Army Maj. Gen. William L. Nash, a former military commander in Bosnia-Herzegovina. "The failure to understand that the civil war is already taking place, just not necessarily at the maximum level, means that our counter measures are inadequate and therefore dangerous to our long-term interest."

And:

"Anthony Cordesman, the Arleigh A. Burke chair in strategy at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, told ABC News, "If you talk to U.S. intelligence officers and military people privately, they'd say we've been involved in low level civil war with very slowly increasing intensity since the transfer of power in June 2004."

And.

Gen. William Odom said the Iraq War is "the greatest strategic blunder in the history of our country."

Posted by Tennessean at March 6, 2006 10:12 AM

When I was in the military we use to have a saying, if it wears stars, it's lying.

Posted by Dave at March 6, 2006 11:26 AM

This is not neo-cons,
this is Wall Street.
The government is on their payroll.
There is no crime these "people" will
not commit to preserve and
multiply their riches.

Posted by ng at March 6, 2006 12:08 PM

This is not neo-cons,
this is Wall Street.
The government is on their payroll.
There is no crime these "people" will
not commit to preserve and
multiply their riches.

Posted by ng at March 6, 2006 12:08 PM

Why does everyone think that Iraq is in the midst of coming apart at the scenes, when it is clear that the country is indeed being rapidly pacified and giving up its military regimen.

A couple of months ago Mr Bush claimed that the Iraqi's had 100 or so battle ready battalions. Shortly after that, the Pentagon announced that number was reduced to one. This past week, final victory was announced, and it was declared that the number of combat prepared battalions is now zero. So we must conclude that the Iraqis have given up all military ambitions, and will settle all future disputes through peaceful discussions in a hot tub.

Posted by m at March 6, 2006 01:05 PM

Wall street has little to do with the military industrial complex. What other industry anywhere in the world is guaranteed a single customer that spends $440,000,000,000. Only a fraction of that money is spent on salaries for active personel. It is in the best interest of the defence contractors to go to war. They need us to use the weapons so we can buy more. Plain and simple.

Now they've started another arms race with the "Reliable Replacement Warhead" program. We are violating the non-proliferation treaty not only with this new deal with India but with the development of new, improved nuclear warheads. What could possible be the rationale behind creating MORE nuclear weapons? Are we going to start nuking the terrorists? Remember the innocent civilians killed in Pakistan because our "intelligence" told us that the #2 terrorist was there? Next time are we going to just nuke them?

The defence contractors hire former politians as "consultants" as in Bush Sr. and the Carlyle Group. Why wouldn't a politian want to increase defence spending when he's promised a seven-figure consulting job when he retires? Just because the money is deferred until they retire doesn't make it less of a bribe.

Posted by Lon at March 6, 2006 02:04 PM

I John Kamalic; am an x marine combat marine that is - 0331 M-60 gunner on the ground with 1st Mar Div. E 2/5 Vietnam 68-69 hit 2x and cancer from agent orange rated 100% disabled with a degree in Political Science Baldwin Wallace college 1977. I have been in the shit and had seen plenty of friendly fire like an air strike called in by our drunk Lt that killed 6 marines from the 1st F4 jet and the 2nd F4 jet dropped 2 Napalm pods and incinerated over 50 old men, women, and children on our perimeter next to a village. Yet, when I complained about it and said when we get back to our fire-base An Hoa I will tell Battalion - what did they do ? They covered it up and on the next op I walked point etc - I have witnessed war crimes murders of Vietnamese civvies and what did command do - nothing but yelled at me and told me to be a team player. And that was back in 68. Look at Tillman in Iraq; I want to tell you; only maybe 60% of the marines I met were good marines; but a strange thing happens when the military tries to turn you into a sociopath for was - you can not turn it off after the war. And some go wild and begin to love it and will do anything to maintain the rush of killing without guilt - how sad. That is why war is hell, and people not properly trained or screened for war - will commit murder and torture - I know - I have seen it - and I have seen some marines not taking it and simply kill themselves in the bush with a 45.
so this Pace guy is a real asshole and a political appointee that will say anything the crackhead Bush wants him to say. I respect Cong. Murtha, and he is a true Marine who speaks the truth in an open society.
I feel bad for Iraq, and Americans and all other forces who are dying for Israel and oil. and the Military Industrial Complex - that he warned about on film in a speech many years ago.

Posted by John Kamalic at March 6, 2006 04:24 PM

John Kamalic:

Good post. I too was in Vietnam in '68-'69. I was at Cu Chi, home of the 25th infantry division. I also have PTSD and Agent Orange in the form of prostate cancer. I have 60% disability and am fortunate because I can still work. I have a M.S. degree in Human Behavior and work with the developmentally disabled. In Vietnam I was part of the FAC team. It was our job to call in airstrikes and drop bombs on people. I agree with Murtha: Pace is a liar and just another Repug shill. We must get out of Iraq NOW. Impeachment of Bush cannot come soon enough. He and his cronies are war criminals and should be prosecuted.

Posted by lickspittle at March 6, 2006 05:50 PM

My experiences in Vietnam were not on the lines with you guys. I was a Navy supply officer and got to see the warbucks people at work. Every day it was a race between Hughes, Skiorsky and Boeing to see who could get the most birds in the air to have the best effectiveness to get orders for more birds.

This Iraq war is just another opportunity for the profiteering bastards to sell their wares at the cost of young American lives.

Posted by Krazo at March 6, 2006 08:46 PM

Good for Murtha. To bad he isn't running for president.

Posted by Joyce at March 6, 2006 09:43 PM

The arabs hold much of our debt as does China & Japan. If one were to suddenly sell it all, the US would be in economic collapse. Could the UAE be blackmailing us on the ports management sale?

Posted by Roger Mallory at March 6, 2006 09:46 PM

Everyone is talking about Iraq, but what about here in the states. NO ONE is talking about the CONCENTRATION CAMPS or that according to REP. CONGRESSMAN RON PAUL of Texas says that our government has FOREIGN TROOPS stationed inside & outside our borders. He said that they are hear "just in case we have MARTIAL LAW". You can find in at www.PrisonPlanet.tv

Posted by Tally at March 7, 2006 05:37 PM

To John Kamalic, I am eternally grateful for your sacrifice and battles of conscience that remain your badges of honor from Vietnam.
None of us are saints but we know the devil when we're staring him in the eyes. Like 'Rosemary's baby', Bush and co. are abominations, born of deceit and ill gain.
I'm a 20 year USNR(Ret.O4) Aviator ('74-'94) and I, like Rep. Murtha (God bless em), would not want to serve in this man's military today. Nor my sons.
My Vietnamese wife, born and raised in DaLat, and our 3 cafe-au-lait sons, now grown, thank you for your love of those innocents from so long ago.
If I outlive you, I will forever honor your memory, en passant.

John V Sullivan

Posted by john sullivan at March 8, 2006 12:00 AM

Post a comment

(Comments are moderated and will not be posted if they contain insults, flaming of other posters, profanity or libelous comments. Comments that are off topic will be deleted. Thanks for waiting.)


Top of Page

RECENT STORIES

Sign up for our Daily Newsletter mailing list!