Capitol Hill Blue is a not-for-profit, non-commercial experiment in on-line journalism published as an information resource for our readers. All material is © 2006 Capitol Hill Blue. For more information, please check out our FAQ. We take your privacy seriously at Capitol Hill Blue.
Home / The Rant / ReaderRant

Capitol Hillbillies


Republicans admit they tried to circumvent law in Schiavo case
By Staff and Wire Reports
Mar 24, 2005, 06:23
Email this article
 
Printer friendly page

Republican leaders in Congress who thought they could illegally order federal judges to ignore the law and follow their wishes are pissed that the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals "failed to adhere to the plain meaning" of the emergency legislation Congress passed over the weekend.

The legislation required that a new, independent evaluation of her case be made, according to papers filed for Speaker Dennis Hastert of Illinois, Majority Leader Tom DeLay and others. They said it also required the courts to "ensure that desperately needed nutritional support" is provided to Schiavo while the review is conducted.

Legal scholars, however, say Congress doesn't have such power and Republicans were dreaming when they thought they could order a specific action by the federal court.

"Congress does not have the authority to direct a decision by a federal court," says Constitutional scholar John Battles. "The judicial branch of government does not answer to the legislative branch."

Republican leaders also admit the Schiavo fight is more about them than the brain-damaged woman in Florida.

Republicans acted on what they perceive to be concerns of religious conservatives who helped the GOP win in November. DeLay, R-Texas, described the Schiavo case in a political context and said conservatives should not retreat because of attacks from the left.

"That's not what Christ asked us to do and they understand that," DeLay said. "It is a political maneuver and they are going to try to destroy the conservative movement and we have to fight back." He made his remarks to the conservative Family Research Council; a recording was made available by a liberal group, Americans United for Separation of Church and State.


Copyright © 2006 Capitol Hill Blue. All rights reserved


We welcome reader comments:
Discuss this story and other issues in ReaderRant.



Top of Page

Capitol Hillbillies
Latest Headlines

George Allen just can't make up his mind on Iraq war
Tough race, influence-peddling probe haunt Rep. Curt Weldon
Republican leader testifies in House page scandal
Ney will cop a plea
Senate Republicans bail on Bush's prisoner plan
Bush's controversial detainee bill headed for Senate floor
Ethics reform bill is more show than go
GOP Senators challenge Bush on terror bill
9/11 resolution debate turns into pissing contest
Advocacy groups want drug pentalty fee removed